Why are SPY and QQQ Unaffected by the Sharp Deterioration in Breadth?

Use CRTL+P to Print

Why are SPY and QQQ Unaffected by the Sharp Deterioration in Breadth?

Use CRTL+P to Print

Welcome to the Chart Fix!

The stock market has become a tale of two markets. QQQ is performing well in September and SPY is flat, but several key groups were hit with strong selling pressure because of the violent moves in oil and rates. Despite a serious deterioration in breadth, SPY and QQQ remain immune because they are driven by a handful of large-cap tech-related stocks. 

Recent Reports and Videos at TrendInvestorPro

  • Selling Pressure Broadens – Copper Leads Commodities Lower
  • Breadth Deteriorates as Credit Markets Show Stress
  • Smalls and Mids Struggle as Yields Rise and Risk Aversion Increases

Next Week at TrendInvestorPro

  • Testing the 200-day Cross and TrendTrio Signals for the Major Indexes
  • Using Sentiment and Capitulation Indicators to Identify Extremes

Click here to take a trial and gain full access.

Rate and Energy Shocks Weigh on non-Tech Groups

September is proving difficult for several key groups, including housing and retail. The PerfChart below shows month-to-date performance for QQQ, SPY, three sector SPDRs and five industry group ETFs. QQQ is up 3.4%, SPY is flat and the rest are down. This is clearly a market of haves and have-nots.

  • Nasdaq 100 ETF (+3.4%)
  • S&P 500 SPDR (+.02%)
  • Russell 2000 ETF (-4.17%)
  • Consumer Discretionary SPDR (-5.38%)
  • Utilities SPDR (-6.80%)
  • Real Estate SPDR (-5.58%)
  • FinTech ETF (-5.80%)
  • Home Construction ETF (-6.17%)
  • Retail SPDR (-4.65%)
  • Solar Energy ETF (-8.62%)
  • Gold Miners ETF (-6.25%)

Selling pressure hit these groups as the 12-month Oil Fund (USL) surged 9% this month and the 10-yr Treasury Yield ($UST10Y) moved from 4.75% to 5.20%.  Large-caps and large-cap techs are more insulated from high interest rates and energy prices.  

S&P 500 Breadth Takes a Hard Hit and Hits Moment of Truth

The next chart shows SPY in the top window and SPX %Above 200-day SMA ($SPXA200R). Chartists can use these two for broad market timing. First and foremost, SPY remains above its rising 200-day SMA and less than 2% from a 52-week high. Thus, SPY is in a long-term uptrend.

Even though SPY held up in September, breadth took a hit as the percentage of S&P 500 stocks above their 200-day SMAs moved from 75% to 47% (-28) over the last five weeks. This is an exceptionally sharp deterioration in breadth. See the pink shadings for prior hits.

Despite a plunge to 47%, the indicator is not yet bearish. In fact, it is at a moment of truth. A move below 40% would turn this indicator bearish, which occurred on March 12th, 2025 (pink arrow). Should the indicator hold above 40% and stabilize, watch for a move above 60% to revive the bulls. Notice how the indicator held above 40% in March and turned up again in April.

TrendInvestorPro maintains a Market Regime page to assess the state of the stock market (bull or bear market). This page includes breadth models, long-term trend signals, yield spreads and Treasury yields. Despite the recent rate shock, the weight of the evidence remains bullish. Note that the Market Regime turned net bullish in July 2025. Click here to take a trial to TrendIvestorPro

Large-cap Tech Stocks and Outsized Gains Drive SPY and QQQ

Breadth is an important metric for the broader market, but less so for SPY and QQQ because they are driven by large-caps and large-cap tech stocks. The top 11 stocks account for 40% of SPY, which means the other 489 account for 60%. The top 11 stocks in QQQ account for 52%, which means the other 89 account for 48%.

The PerfChart below shows month-to-date performance for SPY and the top eleven holdings. Eight are up and three are down (MSFT, AMZN, AVGO). Three are up more than 10% and two are up more than 30% (META, AMD). These outsized gains are making up for weakness elsewhere. Also notice that these eleven stocks are part of the tech sector or the MAG7 group. It’s all up to tech and the MAG7. 

The PerfChart below shows month-to-date performance for QQQ and the top eleven holdings. Nine are up and two are down (MSFT, AMZN). Four are up double digits and three of these four are up more than 30% (AMD, META, INTC).  Again, outsized gains in these three are powering QQQ this month. Big gains in top holdings more than offset weakness elsewhere.

Here are three considerations when trading SPY and QQQ.

  1. Ignore broad breadth because the other 489/89 stocks are not the key drivers.
  2. Focus on largest stocks within these ETFs for clues on underlying strength.
  3. Analyze the price charts for trends and trading signals.

TrendInvestorPro covers SPY, QQQ, XLK and the leading tech-AI ETFs every week. We take our signals from price action and focus on the leading groups. Click here to learn more about our reports, videos and strategies.

Rate and Energy Shock Weigh – Gold Headwinds – Ag and Uranium Set Up

QQQ and Tech stocks are going it alone as high energy prices and surging Treasury yields weigh on the rest of the market. Oil is up 20% over the last four weeks and the 10-yr yield surged 50 basis points, exceeding 5%. High energy prices and high interest rates are one thing, while an accelerating rate of ascent is another. We have seen an energy and interest rate shock this month. Gold is holding up relatively well, but there are headwinds for precious metals. Copper, base metals and agriculture remain in clear uptrends, while uranium sets up with a bull flag. $UST10Y $UST2Y $USL $UGA $USD $GLD $GDX $SLV $CPER $DBB $DBA $SRUUF

Rate and Energy Shock Weigh – Gold Headwinds – Ag and Uranium Set Up Read More »

Semiconductor Equipment & Testing Stocks Correct within Uptrends – 6 Setups

The Semiconductor ETF (SMH) and the Semiconductor ETF (SOXX) are off to the races again with AMD and Intel (INTC) leading the charge. Today’s report focuses on semiconductor equipment stocks. These are the companies that supply the tools needed to manufacture and test semiconductors. Semiconductor Equipment stocks account for 16.6% of SOXX and 18.5% of SMH. At the end of the chart analysis, I included an AI overview of the industry group and some key stocks. $AMAT $LRCX $ASML $TER $AEHR $SMH $SOXX

Semiconductor Equipment & Testing Stocks Correct within Uptrends – 6 Setups Read More »

Bifurcation Beneficiaries – Early August Breakouts Back in Play for Tech, Semis, AI

There is some serious bifurcation in the stock market right now, but this has yet to affect SPY, which is heavily weighted towards the Technology sector. Tech and AI are strong since August, but Industrials, Retail and Housing are weak. This is a sort of rolling rotation where money moves out of one part and into another. Today’s report will focus on the leaders: tech, AI, MAGS, cybersecurity, software and cloud. $SPY $QQQ $XLK $XLC $MAGS $AIQ $ARTY $SMH $DRAM $SKYY $CIBR $IGV

Bifurcation Beneficiaries – Early August Breakouts Back in Play for Tech, Semis, AI Read More »

Leaders, Laggards and the Weakest in MAG7 – Two Bullish Setups and One Bearish

Performance within the Mag7 ETF is mixed with two clear leaders, two clear laggards and a downtrend. Apple and Nvidia have the strongest uptrends. Alphabet is consolidating within an uptrend and trying to turn up. Amazon is in a choppy uptrend with a tradable pullback underway. Meta and Microsoft are all over the place with volatile swings the last few months. Telsa is the basket case of the group with a long-term downtrend and bearish setup. $AAPL $NVDA $GOOGL $AMZN $META $MSFT $TSLA

Leaders, Laggards and the Weakest in MAG7 – Two Bullish Setups and One Bearish Read More »

Rising Rates Weigh on Gold and Small-caps – GLD Hits Moment of Truth

Commodities, stocks and the Dollar are higher since March, while gold and bonds are lower. I picked March because this is when the war with Iran broke out and oil surged. The 12-month Oil Fund (USL) is up some 47% since March. Other commodity groups are also higher (base metals, copper and agriculture). $GLD $GDX $SLV $UST2Y $SPY $IWM $RSP $CPER $DBB $USL $SRUUF $BLOK

Rising Rates Weigh on Gold and Small-caps – GLD Hits Moment of Truth Read More »

HCA and UHS Attempt to Bottom – LMT and RTX Become Oversold

Today’s report focuses on two stocks from the Healthcare Providers ETF (IHF) and two from the Aerospace & Defense ETF (ITA). IHF is leading the market as it consolidates near its highs. HCA Corp and Universal Health Services show signs of bottoming over the last few months. Aerospace & Defense was leading the market in August, but took a hard hit over the last four weeks. Lockheed Martin and RTX Corp pulled back within the group and became oversold within their uptrends. $LMT $RTX $HCA $UHS

HCA and UHS Attempt to Bottom – LMT and RTX Become Oversold Read More »

SPY-QQQ-XLK Hold Up – Semis Moment of Truth – MAGS Leads – 2 Healthcare ETFs

The weight of the evidence remains bullish for stocks, but oil, interest rates and inflation are taking their toll on parts of the market. Small-caps are bearing the brunt of recent selling pressure with large-caps and large-cap techs holding up better since August. Semis are at a moment of truth, while the AI/Tech ETFs are holding their breakouts. Elsewhere, I am seeing bullish setups in Regional Banks, Telecom, Healthcare Providers and Medical Devices. $SPY $QQQ $XLK $IWM $AIQ $ARTY $SMH $SOXX $DRAM $IHI $IHF $KRE

SPY-QQQ-XLK Hold Up – Semis Moment of Truth – MAGS Leads – 2 Healthcare ETFs Read More »

SPY in Leading Uptrend, but New Lows Expand – Two Signals to Watch

SPY is within 3% of a 52-week high, but small-caps took a hit and new lows are expanding. This expansion, however, has yet to derail a bullish signal from May 2025. Today’s report will review this bullish signal and show the key levels to watch. We will also set bear market thresholds for SPY and new lows. $SPY !NEWHISPX !NEWLOSPX $SPXHLP

SPY in Leading Uptrend, but New Lows Expand – Two Signals to Watch Read More »

Bearish Intermarket – Gold Hits Setup Zone – Copper Leads – Blockchain Breakout

The intermarket picture is negative for the average stock (equal-weights, small-caps and mid-caps). Rates are rising and this rise is accelerating. Rising oil prices are stoking inflation. Value and energy are leading within the stock market, while consumer discretionary and industrials move lower. Tech and semis are holding up well since August, and keeping SPY/QQQ afloat. Today’s report also covers gold, copper, uranium and blockchain. $IEF $UST2Y, $UST10Y, $XLY $GLD $CPER $SRUUF $BLOK

Bearish Intermarket – Gold Hits Setup Zone – Copper Leads – Blockchain Breakout Read More »

Oil-Energy Lead – Utes Hit Bullish Zone – Small-caps Correct – Breadth Takes a Hit

Technology, energy and utilities moved higher on Tuesday, while the other eight sectors closed lower. Performance was also lopsided within the technology sector. Semis (SOXX, SMH, DRAM) moved higher, while the MAG7 (MAGS), Software (IGV), Cloud (SKYY), Cybersecurity (CIBR) and Fintech (FINX) moved lower. Tuesday is just one day, but the split has been building since August. Tech and semis are holding up, but there are sizable pockets of weakness that include consumer discretionary and housing. $USL $XLE $XLU $IJR $IJH !GT200SPX

Oil-Energy Lead – Utes Hit Bullish Zone – Small-caps Correct – Breadth Takes a Hit Read More »

Tech-AI Lead in Rolling Rotation – Wedge Breakouts Hold for QQQ, XLK and Co.

While there are some sizable pockets of weakness within the market and rolling rotations underway, the weight of the evidence remains bullish. It is still a bull market. Tech surged in April-May, corrected in June-July and resumed its leadership in August-September. Tech leadership came at the expense of industrials, utilities, housing and retail, which moved lower. Seasonally, September is one of the weakest months for stocks. Perhaps this seasonal pattern is already playing out in some of the more economically sensitive areas. $SPY $QQQ $XLK $AIQ $ARTY $IYZ $SKYY $IGV $CIBR

Tech-AI Lead in Rolling Rotation – Wedge Breakouts Hold for QQQ, XLK and Co. Read More »

Using Breadth and BBands for Oversold Setups in the Semiconductor ETF (SMH)

The Semiconductor ETF fell pretty hard in July, but the decline was always viewed as a correction because it met the retracement requirements and formed a typical corrective pattern. Chartists looking for signals that a correction is ending can turn to Percent B and SMH %Above 50-day SMA. Both became oversold in July and one became oversold in early September. This means SMH is again setting up bullish as it corrects within a bigger uptrend. $SMH !GT40SMH

Using Breadth and BBands for Oversold Setups in the Semiconductor ETF (SMH) Read More »

Semiconductor ETFs Set Up with Corrections – Plus Nvidia, Micron, Taiwan Semi

The Semiconductor ETFs (SMH & SOXX) and the Memory ETF (DRAM) broke out with surges into August and then corrected into early September. The August breakouts were medium-term bullish and the current corrections provide short-term setups. This report will identify the patterns at work, the key levels to watch and the one showing relative strength. $SMH $SOXX $DRAM $NVDA $TSM $MU

Semiconductor ETFs Set Up with Corrections – Plus Nvidia, Micron, Taiwan Semi Read More »

Breadth for Trading Bias and Oversold Conditions – Industrials and Aero/Defense

The Industrials SPDR was hit hard over the last two weeks, but the long-term trend remains up and oversold conditions are present. Today’s report will show a long-term breadth indicator to define the trading bias and three short-term breadth indicators to identify oversold conditions. Attention then turns to XLI’s largest industry group, the Aerospace & Defense. $XLI !GT200XLI !GT50XLI !GT20XLI $ITA

Breadth for Trading Bias and Oversold Conditions – Industrials and Aero/Defense Read More »

Energy, Ag and Metals Trend Higher – Dollar Breakdown – Uranium Throwback

Commodities remain strong as a group. Oil is trading near new highs as the 12-month Oil Fund extends on its triangle breakout. Copper is consolidating near a 52-week high, the DB Agriculture ETF hit a new high and gold broke out in early August. Perhaps even more telling, middle distillates, such as heating oil and diesel are trading near new highs. $USL $USD $GLD $CPER $DBB $SRUUF $DBA

Energy, Ag and Metals Trend Higher – Dollar Breakdown – Uranium Throwback Read More »

Energy Leads – Rates Surge – Junk Bonds Break – Housing & Discretionary Hit

Even though the weight of the evidence remains bullish for stocks, there are some sizable pockets of weakness in key areas. This weakness is exacerbated by strength in the energy sector, which is not the sector we want to see leading the market. The Energy SPDR hit a new high this week as the 12-month Oil Fund exceeded its summer highs. $XLE $XLK $IEF $UST10Y $JNK $XLY $XLC $ITB

Energy Leads – Rates Surge – Junk Bonds Break – Housing & Discretionary Hit Read More »

Oil, Rates, Seasonality & Breadth – QQQ/XLK Test Breakouts – Semis Struggle

The weight of the evidence remains bullish for stocks, but the macro picture is mixed as rates continue to rise, oil prices remain high and September seasonal patterns loom. Small-caps fell over the last two weeks as breadth weakened, while QQQ and XLK successfully defended their wedge breakouts. The Semiconductor ETFs are struggling and I am raising my re-evaluation levels for some of the AI ETFs. $UST2Y $UST10Y $USL $SPXA200R $SPXHLP $SPY $QQQ $XLK, $SMH $SOXX $DRAM $AIQ $ARTY $DTCR $IDGT $UFOX $IYZ $BLOK

Oil, Rates, Seasonality & Breadth – QQQ/XLK Test Breakouts – Semis Struggle Read More »

Aerospace/Defense Leads XLI Pullback, but Big Trends Are Up – 3 Stock Setups

Led by weakness in the Aerospace & Defense ETF, the Industrials SPDR took a hit in the second half of August. Despite this hit, both ETFs are in long-term trends and setting up after short-term pullbacks. Attention then turns to bullish setups in three Aerospace & Defense stocks: GE Aerospace, Lockheed Martin and Howmet. $XLI $ITA $GE $LMT $HWM

Aerospace/Defense Leads XLI Pullback, but Big Trends Are Up – 3 Stock Setups Read More »

Scroll to Top